They want our Facebook log-in info! Run away!
March 26th, 2012 |
The latest social media kerfuffle is over news that some employers are requiring job candidates to disclose their social networking log-in credentials. (Shel Israel does an excellent analysis and summary of the fine points of this story, so I won’t do that here).
Foregoing a discussion about why employers would need this information, this is the kind of silly, panic-inducing story journalists (online and offline) are in love with. It’s the latest in a string of opportunities to cry out with indignation, “Look what they’re doing to us now!” and to then step forward and announce “They’ve gone too far!” (Remember how foursquare was going to help burglars know when you’re gone?)
I’m a huge advocate for privacy. I’ve written and spoken about it often. And while this particular story is not worth getting one’s knickers in a knot over, the pure-anti-social-networking luddites are ignoring our time-honored tradition of surrendering privacy. To quote my friend Scott McNealy, former Sun Microsystems CEO, “You have no privacy. Get over it.” In other words, we gave away certain rights to privacy a long time ago.
We already give employers our social security number, our driver’s license or passport number, our address, and phone number. We agree to a credit check. If we sign up for direct deposit or arrange a wire transfer, we give out our checking account number and ABA routing number. Companies are tracking every keystroke you make and every IP address you visit while at work. Some jobs require employees to submit bodily fluids for drug testing.
If you want to work in aerospace, the intelligence community, or the U.S. Treasury, you can bet they’ll know everything about you from the name of your third-grade teacher to the average number of squares of toilet paper you use each time.
We trade in information. That’s not new and it’s not a function of social media. The great Facebook password disclosure debacle is a straw man enabling the time honored Luddite tradition of crying out, “Watch out for that social media!”
And if a company wants to know about me through what I post on Facebook, I have a solution I could certainly live with. Recruiters could have authenticated company-sponsored Facebook accounts and candidates could be asked to accept friend requests from these recruiters.



Tags: 

I have an easier solution than friending a company that asks for this info. Say no. Repeat it again. And on the third time say, “Screw you. I’m going to use my social media leverage to make sure my ‘friends’ know your company sucks.” My solution is better as it solves the problem, and does not become part of the problem.
I don’t want to friend my employer. Do you think any employer would truly be happy with your option anyway? As soon as I added the person I would add them to my “Sees nothing” locked down list (the one my coworkers and parents are on). They don’t just want your timeline. The want our chat logs and your conversations and messages. Ask Leo Laporte how fun that is next time you see him.
Comment by Christopher L. Jorgensen — March 26, 2012 @ 7:20 pm
I hear you, Christopher, but I just don’t care about my semi/private info that I’ve posted on the public web. All kinds of people know where I live and work, who my friends are, and what my politics are without using Facebook.
In my profession I know hundreds of people in similar roles, many at companies that might be prospective employers. I don’t know from secrets.
Comment by joel — March 26, 2012 @ 7:41 pm
Yeah, I live my life online. You can pretty much find out anything you want to know about me with a simple google search, but I also know the other side of privacy.
One of the problems you have is not everyone feels the way you and I do. So this means that the only people you can ethically communicate with on Facebook are the people who agree to have their information out there as well. Otherwise you’re back to the same point. So while you might be proud to put that you’re in a relationship with your wife (for example) she might prefer to keep her relationship “secret.”
I also doubt that companies will be happy just “being friends,” since this give you the control over what they see. If it’s not on google it’s not public in my mind. If it;s not public your employer has no right to the information.
Comment by Christopher L. Jorgensen — March 28, 2012 @ 12:28 pm