Microworkers Paid Less Than a Penny for Writing
October 29th, 2009 |
Technology has made many things possible, and is enabling unethical people to pay as little as one quarter cent per word for their writing. The Internet is the great democratizer. It is also the great enslaver of the disadvantaged and the marginalized.
Freelance writers, often students, mothers, and older people, are the victims of a global conspiracy to pit people against each other to auction their skills and time for as little as possible.
One of the culprits is Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (MT). Amazon didn’t invent microworking, which is the practice of paying independent contractors by the task instead of by the hour. But they are the first globally recognized company to put their name on the practice, thereby endorsing it and making it an acceptable business practice.
Amazon MT is a service that allows businesses to contract with Amazon to have people perform very brief, discreet operations like manually forwarding an e-mail based on subject matter or moderating blog comments. My son, a student, worked for MT moderating pictures for a social network at the rate of a few pennies each.
ShortTask is another example of a service that brings together businesses and people who want to do microcontract work. In addition to facilitating this process, ShortTask often has questionable tasks like paying for positive product reviews and blog comments, Diggs, Twitter followers, etc.
And last night, someone tweeted a link to Article Slash, which had this posting:
“Hi, I need a group of writers or writing teams who can deliver 20-30 articles of 300 words every day. Payout will be made everyday through paypal.. 0.75$ for every 300 word article.”
Seventy-five cents per article! That’s .0025 per word, one quarter of a penny! If you could write 1200 words per hour (I’m a professional writer and I can’t), you could make $3 an hour doing this.
Our current minimum wage in California is $8, and the federal minimum is $7.25. As bad as that is, there are millions of Californians who would think they had died and gone to heaven to get $8 an hour. The rate at which people work and the quality expected by buyers varies, but the wages offered by these services, like the 75-cent, 300-word article, are equivalent to under $2 an hour. The last time the federal minimum wage was below $2 was in 1974.
Both California state and federal law require* that pieceworkers be paid a rate that is equal to or more than minimum wage, except for students and “new learners” (people who have never done the job before) who are paid at 85% of the minimum wage. Of course this is for regular employees, not contractors.
Some of the inevitable byproducts of this trend are:
- Devaluation of good writing, research and analysis
- Illiteracy
- Theft of editorial content
Microworking is an area in which the law has not caught up with technology and common practice. And the marketplace for these services is mostly underground, so the average person isn’t aware of it or upset by it. The operators of sites like Article Slash and ShortTask may argue that they are merely facilitators, and not responsible for the behavior of their users.
Ours is supposedly a free market economy, but we also have checks and balances so that everyone from the soup kitchen to the boardroom is protected from abuse. As the economic recovery slowly ticks up, one can only hope that supply and demand moderate the wages for microworkers so they are fairly paid for their effort and intellect. Unfortunately, the practices, which may have been made necessary by the downturn, will be status quo for some companies who will be unable to resist the appeal of continued lower operating costs.
* This is based on my research and interpretation of government documents. I am not an attorney and could be wrong about this.
| Sphere This |



Tags: 

The average skill of a secretary or office assistant 45 - 50 wpm typist the calculation equates to about 6.75 per hour which is within the legal wage requirement. Most people can type accurately at 20 - 25 wpm based on this Wikipedia link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Words_per_minute.
As a matter of accuracy.
I understand that there many people out there looking for jobs but many of those who do not have a job are unable to obtain internet access unless they “steal” it form an open Wi-Fi connection. I would think this is a fair price per word.
However I do agree they should be policed for fair pay for an honest days work.
Comment by Bill James — November 13, 2009 @ 2:34 pm
Interestingly your title coined the term “microworkers”. There’s actually a microworkers.com website offering such a writting service just like Mturk.com. Although, I think microworkers.com is a bit easier to use than mturk.com. I agree, 75 cents for 300 words article is way too low.. I wish these sites would raise the minimum to at least $5 per article.
Comment by Josh Byerson — January 23, 2010 @ 11:43 pm
I agree with you. It is outrageous. $5 an article isn’t even enough. What happened to Quality Standards. Why are people so afraid to pay for quality? You are right, it does devalue the work. It also makes it difficult to compete. I don’t think anyone should have to work for less than a penny per word or less than a certain amount an hour, not just me.
The problem is the incredible standard of living gap between the global south and the global elite.
People are jumping at the opportunity to make $.36 an hour or less, or get paid a quarter of a penny per word as their standards of living are so poor.
The global economic system is to blame. As are we, the global elite who have the power to at least try to stop this.
We would either have to make this practice illegal and make some kind of penalty (which isn’t easy, and can backfire) or else the world, collectively, would have to say “I am worth more” and absolutely stop supporting them.
Though the problem with that would be what I call the “Disney Fall Out” — When a factory (or company like Article Slash) pulls out it’s albeit crappy infrastructure from a severely impoverished population and creates almost more devastation than them being there in the first place.
I’m turning this into my soapbox, so I’ll stop here, but I want to thank you for this article! Thank you! We should have a discussion on this again.
Comment by Amber — February 18, 2010 @ 8:51 pm
Hmm…in my opinion, microworkers should built some gradual quality standard in job qualification,if there is workers that finished their jobs with middle quality result,so he/she will be paid based on their quality with range result ! not based on their job result,so there should be earning range for each job…
Comment by Mif — February 22, 2010 @ 7:34 pm